Perfectly Pie

ABOUT US

Perfectly Pie is a female owned and operated small business that proudly serves north and central Florida.

HOW WE STARTED

As a young child, I grew up watching the strong, hard-working women in my family serve the household in any way they could. Many times, that backbone-support of our household came from scratch cooking out of our meager undersized kitchen. With cast iron skillets, old fashioned churned butter and flour dusted heavy wooden rolling pins, they didn’t cut any corners. From my childhood, I have always loved and admired being a part of crafting scratch-made and hand-designed pies like my grandmother, mother and aunts did before me. I am so thankful for the baking practices that I was able to glean from my family heritage. Over the years, as I have been able to put into practice what was handed down to me, I have grown my skills and evolved into a pie baking enthusiast. Here at Perfectly Pie, we take great pride in being able to serve the community scratch-made, hand-crafted pie that continues to bring back those special childhood memories.

WHAT WE OFFER

Not just another store-bought, dime a dozen, flavorless pie from your big box vendor, but a hand-crafted and scratch-made dessert to order. Your dessert is given care and attention to detail with everything from quality ingredients to timely delivery and everything in between.

Understanding that each pie is individually made with quality ingredients, I have adjusted my prices due to soaring inflation on food and farmed goods. Prices may vary as the 2024 Holiday season nears.

$10 DELIVERY CHARGE ON ALL ORDERS.

PIE MENU / PRICE LIST

SPECIALTY PIES

Signature Dutch Apple Pie

$44

4.5 lbs. of layers and layers of fresh applies, full of seasoning and spice and loaded with a Dutch crumble topping.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cream Pie

$38

This pie is for those on the naughty list. Rich, creamy peanut butter and chocolate chip filling with a crunch of Reese’s candy in a graham cracker crust.

Old Fashion Chocolate Fudge Pie

$38

Who wants chocolate? Served chilled or warm, this pie is loaded with rich, creamy fudge in every bite. Cool Whip topping is available.

Traditional Pumpkin Pie

$36

All things pumpkin with traditional harvest spices and scratch-made crust.

Classic Pecan Pie

$42

Elegant twist on a delicious classic pecan pie paired with flaky scratch-made crust.

Key Lime Pie

$42

Sweet and tangy in every bite with a graham cracker crust. Fresh squeezed key limes used for every pie.

Coconut Cream Pie

$42

A southern signature. You’ll fall in love with coconut all over again after tasting this homemade cream filling with cool whip and sprinkled with coconut flakes inside and out.

Sweet Potato Pie

$42

Scratch-made crust loaded with real creamy sweet potato filling, seasoned and spiced to perfection.

Simple Strawberry Pie (Seasonal)

$44

(Always fresh when produce is available. We never use frozen or canned fruit.) This pie takes strawberry to another level! Scratch-made crust loaded with real strawberry filling.

WELCOME